Worship Times: Sat 5 pm | Sun 8 am + 10:30 am | Tue + Thu 12:05 pm Details and Directions

St Paul's logo

St. Paul’s Pie Classic

Some churches have golf tournaments or bingo games, but at St. Paul’s, we have pie. Each November, the many bakers among us compete in the St. Paul’s Pie Classic. There are three categories: Fruit, Cream, and Savory. We like pie, but aren’t pie snobs: a tart, a quiche, or even a cobbler is as welcome as a traditional pie.

A winner is chosen in each category, and one pie is chosen as the winner of the contest. The winner of each category receives a gift card to Starbucks, and the grand prize winner receives a gift certificate to Pryde’s Old Westport. Pies are judged between the services on Sunday morning, winners announced at the 10:30 service, and then the pies are consumed at coffee hour after church. This is always a big Sunday at St. Paul’s, and everyone has a lot of fun and a lot of pie.

  • Grand Prize “Best in Show” (2015) Nancy Lacy, Blueberry Custard Pie
  • Sweet (2015) Anne Jetter Maas, Oatmeal Pie
  • Savory (2015) Daniel Hannes w/ Leora Nauta & Kelly Phelan, Pear, Brie & Bacon Tart
  • Prettiest (2015) Jennifer Coen, Coconut, Chocolate Pie
  • Judge’s Choice (2015) Leora Nauta, Canadian Maple Tart